Retail Portfolio review
Progress on our key objectives for 2009/10
Protect income through proactive asset management
- Secured £27m lettings and reduced units in administration from 5.1% to 1.8%
- Achieved rental growth at key locations, including Gunwharf Quays, Portsmouth; The Galleria, Hatfield and the N1 Centre, Islington
Continue to make sales as appropriate
- Sold Bullring, Birmingham, as had no active role in asset management and were unable to utilise asset for debt purposes
- Sold 50% share of Exeter assets while retaining responsibility for asset management and future development
Identify acquisition and uplift opportunities
- Acquired The Atlas Site, Glasgow, helping us to maximise the development potential of our Buchanan Street holdings
- Achieved planning success to enhance Sainsbury’s foodstores in Lincoln and Wandsworth, through Harvest Partnership
Maintain position as best-in-class for development and customer service
- Enabled John Lewis Partnership to launch its first new format ‘at home’ shop, in Poole, Dorset
- Retail customer satisfaction survey score remained consistently high at 4.17
Complete and maximise lettings at current developments
How we create value
We aim to deliver growing rental income streams, higher investment values and future development opportunities by:
At the start of the year the economic outlook continued to cast a shadow over retail property investment values, but the picture improved significantly as we moved towards and beyond the half-year point, with growing investor demand for shopping centres and retail warehouses. We saw a pronounced rise in values for retail warehousing, which was a result of particularly strong buying interest from institutional investors.
While occupier markets remained tough this year, well located retail assets in a good catchment continue to attract retailers. We saw consistent leasing activity from a number of well-known brands both in shopping centres and the retail warehouse market.
The valuation of our Retail Portfolio resulted in a surplus for the year of 11.7% overall, with shopping centres and shops up 8.3% and retail warehouses and food stores up 22.5%.
Rental values in our like-for-like portfolio fell 6.3% for our shopping centres and shops, and 4.7% for our retail warehouses and food stores over the year as a whole. However, the rate of decline was ameliorating as the year progressed and, in the second half, rental values fell by just 0.7% for shopping centres and shops, and by 0.2% for our retail warehouses and food stores.
On the basis of ungeared total property returns, our shopping centres outperformed the IPD Quarterly Universe by 6.9% and our retail warehouses outperformed by 0.75%. The primary reasons for this outperformance were higher levels of occupancy coupled with the completion of a number of key asset management initiatives.
We significantly reduced the proportion of units in administration from 5.1% in March 2009 to 1.8% at year-end. Voids across our like-for-like Retail Portfolio were 5.8% compared to 5.1% at March 2009. Within this 5.8% void figure, 1.8% is occupied under temporary lettings. These results reflect good leasing progress assisted by our established relationships with retailers.
Table 33: Net rental income
|31 March 2010
|31 March 2009
|Like-for-like investment properties||228.5||242.0||(13.5)
|Proposed development properties||7.2||8.6||(1.4)
|Acquisitions since 1 April 2008||0.2||–||0.2|
|Sales since 1 April 2008||20.2||55.2||(35.0)|
|Non-property related income||3.7||5.4||(1.7)|
|Net rental income||279.2||318.5||(39.3)|
Despite recent turbulence in our market, our strategy has remained clear, consistent and in tune with evolving retail trends. We work to ensure our shopping centres – both large and small – provide shoppers with convenience, great leisure experiences and a breadth of successful retail brands. And we continue to develop our retail warehouse portfolio so major brands can provide attractive and convenient out-of-town options for shoppers.
We look to improve assets, raising them up the retail hierarchy and positioning them to become dominant in their catchment. Our key objective is to maximise long-term returns from our portfolio.
Sales and acquisitions
This year asset sales totalled £625.5m. On average, sales were at 1.6% below the 31 March 2009 valuation (before disposal costs) and showed an average income yield of 7.6%. We chose to sell assets that offered less opportunity to create value through development and active asset management.
The largest disposal related to our one-third ownership in the Bullring, Birmingham, which was sold to the Future Fund of Australia for close to £210m in September 2009. We had no operational control of the Bullring asset and saw limited opportunities to create additional value through asset management.
In December 2009, we sold a 50% share of our leasehold interests in Exeter city centre to The Crown Estate for close to £100m. This transaction has enabled us to extract capital while retaining the asset management, property management and future development functions for this estate.
Other asset disposals this year included retail warehouse parks and food stores in Bury, Melton Mowbray, Plymouth, Liverpool, Edmonton, Swansea and Chester, together with shopping centres in Maidstone and Welwyn.
After conversion to REIT status in 2007 we became a net seller of retail assets and initially enjoyed the capital gains tax benefits REIT status brings to transactions. Even as we moved into the downturn we succeeded in making good sales. In 2007 and 2008 we disposed of nine retail warehouse assets with a combined value of £300m, at an average yield of 5.2%. In 2009 we sold a further five assets for £170m bringing the combined average yield up to 6.2% for this whole period. We have sold many of our older retail warehouse assets, some dating back to the early 1980s and now have a very robust portfolio, with a low level of voids and significant opportunities for development and enhancement.
In December 2009 we completed the purchase of the property known as The Atlas Site for just under £10m – a relatively small but important transaction that demonstrates how we create value. Located on Glasgow’s Buchanan Street, The Atlas Site is directly opposite the Buchanan Galleries shopping centre, which we jointly own with Henderson Global Investors. Ownership of the new asset will help us to maximise the development potential of our Buchanan Street holdings, as we work to cement its place as the dominant pitch in this major city.
Our asset management initiatives across our centres have also created encouraging results. Our factory outlet centres continue to prove attractive to retailers and consumers alike with the convenience, value and breadth of their choice. At Gunwharf Quays in Portsmouth, sales grew by 6.7% over the year helped by new lettings to Fiorelli, Quba Sails, Yo Sushi and Wagamama. The Galleria at Hatfield has also seen good progress, with Gap, Jaeger, Laura Ashley and Gant new to the centre. Across our shopping centre portfolio, we have seen emerging instances of being able to secure higher rents for the right unit in the right location. An example is at the N1 Centre in Islington where the former Borders unit attracted a significant amount of interest and H&M ultimately beat several competitors for the space at a rental level considerably higher than the previous rent. In Aberdeen, the centre has responded well to recently opened competition with lettings to Hobbs, Jo Malone, Phase 8 and Swarovski helping reinforce the fashion offer of the centre. Towards the end of the year we obtained a resolution to grant planning permission for 4,350m2 of extension space at White Rose in Leeds which will help satisfy demand from retailers to upsize and, since the year end, we have signed a lease for a new 1,860m2 store for H&M.
During the year we continued to see retailer demand for space in the retail warehouse sector, and secured new lettings at our Livingston, Dundee, Thanet and West Thurrock retail parks. In October 2009 the first of the new format John Lewis shops opened in Poole, Dorset. This 5,110m2 shop sells the retailer’s home, electrical and home technology products. The retailer believes there could be potential for up to 30 new locations if the trial proves successful. By choosing to work with us on this important project, John Lewis has highlighted our ability to build lasting relationships and deliver great sites. Our work with John Lewis – and with J Sainsbury through the Harvest Partnership – underlines both the increasing attraction of the retail warehouse sector for major brands and our excellent track record in this area.
We continue to introduce initiatives to strengthen our relationships with retailers. Our new Clearlet leases are proving popular, and we intend to introduce more of these on new lettings to help speed up and simplify the leasing process. Clearlet leases are straightforward contracts that simplify key aspects of the landlord-tenant relationship.
In October 2009, we opened the St David’s Shopping Centre in Cardiff. Created with our partners, Capital Shopping Centres PLC, the centre is anchored by a new John Lewis department store – the first in Wales and the largest outside London. The new development links to the existing Debenhams and Marks & Spencer stores, which were refitted to coincide with the opening. The centre is now 74% let or in solicitors’ hands by income – a satisfactory result in a tough market. Although it was launched in difficult economic conditions, St David’s is located in the centre of a major city and is anchored by high quality retailers. We believe it will become a dominant asset and has good future growth potential.
Having obtained planning consent to provide 70,000m2 of new retail space at our Leeds Trinity shopping centre development, we have made good progress in discussions with retailers and are increasingly confident about starting the scheme in 2010 as we move towards the pre-lettings target we have set prior to development.
Over the coming months we expect to see continued buying interest for retail investment property and more retailers leasing space. There is a relatively high level of available space, so rental trends are likely to remain flat in the short term before returning to moderate growth. Despite these market dynamics, we have scope to drive growth in capital values by continuing to lease up vacant space, particularly in our shopping centre assets.
We have a very clear view of how our market is evolving and which trends are most likely to shape our future. Intensive research into the retail market has given us insights into the way consumer needs, habits and aspirations are changing, and the effect of online shopping and other technologies on physical retailing. The insights gained are now guiding our strategy.
While the internet will attract customer spend, consumers continue to value the immediacy, convenience and community offered by physical shops, together with the ability to see, feel and take home products. These advantages mean bricks and mortar shops have a vital role to play in retailing for years to come. While online shopping may increase competition for some retailers, we also believe the growth of multi-channel retailing, digital marketing and mobile technology will create many new opportunities and benefits for retailers with access to high quality retail space.
Over time, the potential casualties of the structural changes are likely to be shops in medium size towns where there is a low quality offer and poor facilities, especially those located near bigger centres. Rental recovery is likely to reflect this, becoming polarised across UK towns and cities according to the level of vacancies and the attraction of individual assets. We saw signs of this polarisation in the second half of the year and expect the trend to continue into 2011 and beyond.
Shoppers continue to value convenience, hence the continued rise of supermarkets, which has taken place in tandem with the growth of online retailing. This is one reason why we are working closely with supermarkets such as J Sainsbury, in our Harvest partnership, and other major retailers, such as John Lewis, on continuing to grow and develop our out-of-town offer.
Key objectives for 2010/11
- Outperform IPD
- Expand our out-of-town presence through new acquisitions and development
- Meet pre-letting targets for development schemes, including Leeds Trinity
- Protect income across our portfolio
- Maintain effective cost control, including capital expenditure and irrecoverable costs associated with shopping centres